I’m not Atheist. I Just Don’t Believe in God

I was born without too many beliefs. In fact I’d be willing to commit to saying that I was born without a single one. But from the instant I was born I began to encounter truths. I could breathe. I could cry. I could eat. I could love.

It was my parents that helped me learn that last. They were the first to love me. They were the first I loved. And as I acquired spoken language, I learned what to call that emotion. I learned that from them. I learned something else from them too: What to believe.

To understand how I think of that word, consider this quote from Newton:

“A man may imagine things that are false, but he can only understand things that are true, for if the things be false, the apprehension of them is not understanding.”

Isaac Newton

I use the word believe for things I imagine to be true, and I use the word know for things that I have proof of. Assuming this distinction, as a kid I didn’t consider that there was a difference between something one believes and something one knows. Admittedly the difference is tenuous when applied to anything but the most basic of truths, and thus easy to attack. For example, I would say I know there are people living in Australia, but since I have never been there I have never observed the truth of it, and so perhaps the most I could claim is that I believe there are people living in Australia. In this way you could say to me that I know very little, and believe much more. I’d have to agree. Maybe we should all keep that in mind as I continue …

My parents taught me about God. They taught me what He wants from me. They taught me what His laws are for the way I am meant to behave, and they taught me to fear and love Him. They taught me I wasn’t allowed to say His name. They sent me to a school where I was taught more about G-d. I was taught that He created the world in six days and needed to rest for a day after that, so we all should too. I was taught He created humans on the 6th of those days, but we more or less immediately made a mess of things and were banished from paradise as a result. I was taught that subsequently for thousands of years, with the exception of an intervention or two, we didn’t know He existed until He decided to choose Abraham, and thus began the Jewish people. My Hebrew name is Abraham. His story meant more to me as a result. I was taught it really happened. I believed it.

Maybe you believe it too. Or maybe you don’t. Either way, I’m not here to tell you what to believe or not to believe. I am spectacularly unqualified to perform that instruction. I am qualified to tell you what happened to me though. It’s not dramatic, but I do often feel like it’s profound. Then again, profundity is in the eye of the beholder … or something like that. But as for myself, I am beholden to my own profound evolution.

The Cleanliness of Mathematics

I was drawn to mathematics in my teens. The cleanliness of it, and the unassailability of the bountiful harvest of truths it offers was like a magnet for my brain. I immersed myself in it in high school, and subsequently earned undergraduate and graduate degrees in it. I am a high school math teacher and university math lecturer. I am a math textbook author. I don’t know how much of my affinity for it was caused by my wiring, and how much of my wiring is a result of the math, but it trained me to think in a certain way, and I am happy that I do. But I do have to go back and challenge one of my claims at the start of this paragraph. Mathematical truths are assailable – sort of.

The Assailability of Truth

Every truth in math, fully proven beyond doubt, is still completely vulnerable in one sense. All you have to do is dig down to the axioms, and then change them. Or maybe challenge them is a better framing.

To understand what an axiom is, think of it like this: it’s an assumption that by definition cannot be proven, but upon which you can build arguments and consequently draw conclusions. An easy math example is the axiom that a straight line can be drawn from any point to any other point. It might make sense – it may even seem obvious – and you may choose to believe it, but there is actually no way to prove it. And it may even be functionally false. Functionally false meaning that if we try to apply it to a real-world scenario we care about, we discover the difficulty. Consider drawing a straight line from Canada to Australia (assuming Australia exists, of course). To do it you either have to penetrate the Earth’s core, which might be viewed as a troublesome requirement, or else you have to “draw” the line over the surface of the Earth. But since the Earth is not flat (apologies to the FE crew – you’re so cute), the line you draw will actually be an arc.

Still, the straight-line axiom is useful. And from that, we can draw (pun not intended but welcome) many conclusions about geometry. However, if you change the axiom, many if not all of your conclusions disintegrate faster than Thanos can snap his fingers. Some may still follow, some will not. But when axioms change we must examine all proofs built on them. Some may survive. Many new ones need to be built.

The best part is that we get entire systems built off a small collection of axioms. These systems can be more or less useful depending on the applicability of the axioms they are built on. If you define a new set of axioms, you get a new system. And assuming they are founded on internally consistent axioms, both systems are equally true in the formal logic sense, in that both follow rigorously from a set of axioms. And although they often are practical, they don’t even need to be, which is often part of the fun.

That sounds complicated. Let me give you a simple math example.

Euclidean vs. Spherical Geometry

The geometry you almost certainly learned in school is actually what we call Euclidean geometry. This geometry starts by assuming all 2-D shapes exist on a flat surface (a plane). It is based on the book Elements written by Euclid around 300 BC. In it, Euclid proposes five postulates (axioms) that form the foundation for what most people simply think of as geometry, when in fact it is more accurately thought of as a geometry.

In Euclidean geometry, parallel lines are essentially defined as two lines that will never meet, regardless of how far they are extended. He then draws the conclusion that if two lines intersect a third line at the same angle, those two lines must be parallel. In Spherical geometry, lines are not drawn on a flat surface (a plane), but rather on a sphere. Imagine the Earth. The equator is a line that goes around the planet. Longitudes are also lines that go around the planet, and they are drawn perpendicular to the equator. So two different longitudes intersect the equator at the same angle (90°), and so are parallel in the Euclidean sense. Yet all longitudes meet at the poles. In Spherical geometry, two lines that intersect a third line at the same angle are not parallel!

And that’s perfectly fine. The geometries are just based on different axioms, and both geometries are useful. The usefulness of Euclidean geometry is apparent everywhere we look. The usefulness of Spherical geometry is apparent any time we take a flight from Canada to the mythical land of Aus.

What’s really cool about this is that in math, we love to fiddle with axioms and see what we get, even if there seems to be no point. The joy is in taking a small set of axioms, then applying pure logic to develop entire systems. And we can switch between systems when we want to, either for a practical purpose or just for the mental exercise.

So What Does This Have to do with Atheism?

Maybe it’s obvious to you. Maybe it isn’t. First off, let me say that there are plenty of mathematicians who are devout in their religious faith. Newton himself, arguably one of the three greatest mathematicians of all time (Archimedes and Gauss being the other two) was a devout Christian. So math-I-wanna is not, in practice, a gateway drug to any kind of faith denial. But it has caused me to ask many questions, and dig down to find the axioms.

Before I begin that explanation, I do want to address one thing, which I have heard prominent atheists (notably Sam Harris) talk about, and which I agree with. Naming an absence of belief in what, to anyone with that absence would call an imaginary entity doesn’t make a whole lot of sense. I do not believe in dragons. I do not believe in unicorns. And as much as I have tried (and tried … and tried) to manipulate objects without touching them, I do not believe in The Force. Yet the only “-ist” you could really name me based on that is realist. There isn’t a word that separates people that don’t believe in dragons from people who don’t believe in the tooth fairy. Interestingly though, if your parents taught you the tooth fairy was real, there was a time during which you believed it. One wonders at the parenting ethics of that. One (okay, me) admits to being guilty of that deception when one’s kids were young. In any case, calling someone an atheist because they don’t believe there is/are a god(s) does seem like taking one specific fiction and naming the refusal to accept it as something more special than it is. Furthermore, because of the lexicographical arena “atheism” lives in, calling it an “-ism” implies a belief system or ideology that really isn’t there.

“If you choose not to decide, you still have made a choice.”

Rush

So what do axioms and systems have to do with atheism? Well here it is. The existence of God is axiomatic. You have to take it on faith. It’s literally the driving force behind many religions – certainly the Abrahamic ones. Many followers will say that they have witnessed proof of God, but in fact what it appears to me to be, in every case, is begging the question (in formal logic, that means assuming something is true in order to prove it). Start by assuming God exists, then witness or experience something and assign its significance as proof they were right.

Or start by believing God might exist and then take something “miraculous” as proof. I can admit that a miracle can be treated as evidence, but it is not proof. Consider a murder investigation. Finding the victim’s watch in an apartment shared by Darryl and Mike could be considered as evidence that Darryl committed the crime, but it’s not proof. And if Darryl were not in the suspect pool, say, because he had an established alibi, and Mike was, investigators would be much more likely to assume the watch was pointing at Mike and continue looking for proof that Mike did it. For the investigators to start including Darryl as a potential suspect, there would have to be significant evidence that made it unavoidable to look at him for the murder, would require dismissing his alibi, and even then it would not be proof he did it. And this whole example rests on our assumption here that there even is a Darryl.

If one were assuming God did not exist, or if one was unaware that a thing called “God” could even be in contention, no apparently miraculous event would be considered evidence of God.

This is not me saying that you should or should not believe in God. Maybe there is one. Maybe there isn’t. This is me saying that there is no proof of God. Your belief in a deity is faith. Your denial of a deity is also faith. This is because believing something is true and believing something is false are both assertions of certainty, and in the case of God, neither assertion can be proven. This despite the fact that many atheists say the burden of proof that something does not exist is an unnecessary burden. Maybe. But you can only know things that are true. Everything else is belief.

The Third Option

I did a sleight of hand up there. I implied you either believe there is a deity, or you believe there is not. But it’s possible to simply not be sure, which is to say, to be agnostic, notwithstanding there is a version of atheism that maintains agnosticism, which, for this framing, can seem confusing for people not versed in the flavours of atheism.

The existence of god(s) is an open question. Maybe yes, maybe no. Proving or disproving it, to date, seems impossible, so while the question itself is sort of interesting, pursuing certainty is not. As Neal Stephenson wrote in Anathem:

That’s funny because if anyone actually did prove the existence of God we’d just tell him ‘nice proof, Fraa Bly’ and start believing in God.

If you want, you can call me agnostic I suppose. But even that term in the common lexicon carries more significance than it deserves.

You’re Not Atheist. You Just Don’t Believe in God. You Are Such an Oxymoron.

Maybe you see it now. Maybe you don’t. I’ll admit to two things about the title of this blog. First, it’s designed as click-bait. If you got this far, maybe it worked. Sorry about that. But more importantly, it’s true. I am not Atheist. I don’t know if God is real or not, but I do believe there must be something. Some energy or formula or something there’s no word for (maybe the word is lowercase g god). I believe this because of what I know. Some examples:

  • Take fifteen people from vastly different cultures and show them the Canadian Rockies and they will agree they’re beautiful.
  • Trace evolution back as far as you can, then even farther. There is either a catalyst back there or there isn’t. Both possibilities are bizarre.
  • Consciousness is a bizarre phenomenon. Descartes said “I think therefore I am.” How do I know Descartes was thinking?
  • Dance can make people cry independent of where they were born and raised.

These phenomena, whatever you want to call them, and whether or not you want to group them in one category, are real as far as I can tell. Denying that seems silly because it denies my own existence. Saying “Yeah, but there’s a scientific explanation for everything” as if that dismisses anything omits the obvious response “Ok, maybe. Probably. But what’s the explanation for science?”

So they lead me to a belief, one I am not asking you to share. I believe there is something. I didn’t say know. I believe it because of what I know. I also can’t say what that thing is, and I am not even trying to. What I do not believe is that whatever it is is sentient, at least in the way that we understand that word, and that it somehow cares about me – if anything, nature shows us it does not. I do not believe that whatever it is requires my belief and my fealty lest I somehow be punished. I definitely do not believe that whatever it is will decide that I am a sinner if I eat a cheeseburger, watch TV on a Saturday, or say its “name” in vain.

So yeah, I am not an atheist. I just don’t believe in God.

Thanks for reading,

Rich